Based in Lafayette, Indiana

Based in Lafayette, Indiana

Share this post

Based in Lafayette, Indiana
Based in Lafayette, Indiana
An ‘Office’ mystery: One man’s search for Dwight Schrute’s shirt

An ‘Office’ mystery: One man’s search for Dwight Schrute’s shirt

Filmmaker Luke Menard, a Harrison and Purdue grad, turns his search for the origin story of wardrobe from the set of ‘The Office’ into a potboiler and a plea. Texting 911 to ‘The Office Ladies’

Dave Bangert's avatar
Dave Bangert
Nov 25, 2022
∙ Paid
1

Share this post

Based in Lafayette, Indiana
Based in Lafayette, Indiana
An ‘Office’ mystery: One man’s search for Dwight Schrute’s shirt
4
Share

Thanks to the sponsors of today’s Based in Lafayette edition, including:

Purdue Convocations, presenting the Black Friday sale. Save 25% on the biggest shows at Purdue, including: the beloved musical CATS, Riverdance 25th Anniversary Show, the iconic Jesus Christ Superstar and more! Gift an experience this year and save BIG at convocations.org

CLICK HERE FOR BLACK FRIDAY 25% SAVINGS ON CONVOS TICKETS

And Purdue University, with a reminder that it takes tolerance and free speech very seriously, believing that responsible debate and deliberation are essential parts of the university’s educational mission. As a national leader on this topic, Purdue will host a panel discussion at 6 p.m. Dec. 5 in Stewart Center’s Fowler Hall focused on the vital role that open debate and civil discourse play in advancing a healthy campus culture of learning. Click the link below to learn more.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE

AN ‘OFFICE’ MYSTERY: ONE MAN’S SEARCH FOR DWIGHT SCHRUTE’S SHIRT

This all starts with what we’re led to believe was a show-worn shirt and tie of Dwight Schrute’s from an episode of “The Office.”

But is it, really?

Luke Menard, a Lafayette native and now a filmmaker in Indianapolis, needs to know.

Filmmaker Luke Menard. (Photo: Luke Menard)

Menard, a Harrison High School and Purdue grad, this week released a 15-minute short, “The Dwight Mystery,” detailing in mockumentary form his search for the origin story of a brown shirt and striped tie he picked up in an online auction after the NBC show ended nearly a decade ago.

With scenes shot in the parking lot of the Staples at Lafayette Market Place and his boyhood home near Battle Ground, the piece documents, more or less, his search through 201 episodes – plus outtakes – for clues.

Littered with references and recreated scenes from the series – including an appearance by Andy Buckley, who sets the mood by recreating a scene his character, David Wallace, played in Season 5 (Episode 8: “Frame Toby”) – Menard and friends try to unravel the nagging secret: What episode did actor Rainn Wilson wear the shirt Menard won at auction?

It’s no “Threat Level Midnight.” Then again, what is?

Instead, it plays as an open plea to “The Office Ladies,” a podcast hosted by actresses Jenna Fischer and Angela Kinsey, to help fill in the backstory.

(Photo: Luke Menard)

Here’s where things stand.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Based in Lafayette, Indiana to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Dave Bangert
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share