Behold! A BiL Holiday Playlist is Born
The songs, and the readers’ stories about why they’re on the 2024 Based in Lafayette Holiday Playlist.
What a great ride it’s been, pulling together this BiL Holiday Playlist three songs at a time.
Here’s a rundown of the fun and far-flung recommendations from Based in Lafayette readers, collected since Thanksgiving.
The recommendation: Put it on shuffle and let it play.
This is how we got there:
Mark Myers
Myers, a native of Auburn, Indiana, is lead choral director at Jefferson High School, overseeing the entire program and directing A Cappella, First Edition and Varsity Singers. He’s taught students from third grade up through graduate music majors, primarily in Chicagoland and Southern California before coming to Lafayette Jeff.
“For Unto Us a Child is Born,” Sounds of Blackness, from “Handel’s Messiah: A Soulful Celebration” (Various Artists) – I’m not sure how 13-year-old me happened open this amazing album, but it opened up my musical world. A geeky music kid from an early age, I had been obsessed with my mother’s old box set of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra and Chorus performing Handel’s Messiah under the baton of Georg Solti, and then this reinterpretation of the oratorio in multiple genres of Africana music came along and blew my mind.
“Snowfall,” The Manhattan Transfer, from “The Christmas Album” – Ironically enough, this came out around the same time as “A Soulful Celebration.” Probably not the most well-known track on this iconic album, but I love the lush harmonies and the nostalgic feelings this arrangement evokes.
“I Got My Love To Keep Me Warm,” Idina Menzel & Billy Porter, from “Christmas: A Season of Love” (Idina Menzel) – I just ran across this red-hot version of the Irving Berlin standard in just the last few weeks on someone else’s playlist! Idina Menzel and Billy Porter, two of the most incredible voices to grace the contemporary Broadway stage, do not disappoint, and the big band orchestrations are extremely well-written and executed.
Kitty Campbell
Kitty Campbell is a local jazz musician who by day can be found at MatchBOX Coworking Studio in her role as executive director of Leadership Lafayette. She originally came to West Lafayette as an assistant director for Purdue Musical Organizations where she performed in more than 50 Christmas Shows at the Elliott Hall of Music. She loves Christmas and finding new takes on holiday favorites.
The Nutcracker, Op. 71, Act 2: No. 14c, Pas de deux. Variation II "Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy & Coda,” André Previn, London Symphony Orchestra – Nothing ushers in the season for me like the Nutcracker Suite. It reminds me of exploring magical storefront windows at Marshall Fields on State Street with my parents before brunch with Santa by the big tree in the Walnut Room. When I was at Purdue Musical Organizations, I always included a selection from the Nutcracker in my instrumental set!
“O Tannenbaum,” The Vince Guaraldi Trio, from “A Charlie Brown Christmas” – This one takes me back to my childhood. A favorite carol honoring my German heritage from my maternal grandfather who was the first generation born in the States. If you're up for rediscovering this holiday classic, check out Isaiah J. Thompson's "A Guaraldi Holiday" released in 2023 just after he won the American Pianist Awards Cole Porter Fellowship.
"Let it Snow! Let it Snow! Let it Snow!" Nancy Wilson, from “A Nancy Wilson Christmas featuring the Dizzy Gillespie Alumni All-Star Band” – While I'm never quite ready for winter weather, this jazz standard gets me in the mood to cozy up by the fire and enjoy the view. I'm a huge Nancy Wilson fan and had the opportunity to see her live at The Blue Note and the New Orleans Jazz & Heritage Festival. Dizzy Gillespie's Alumni All-Star Band is the icing on the yule log!
Bonyea Killebrew
Bonyea Killebrew is a composer and the keyboard/winds player and musical director for The Velocity District. He also plays in the Lafayette Citizens Band.
"Rocky Point Holiday," Ron Nelson (Recorded by the Dallas Wind Symphony) – Pretty advanced but nice holiday sounding piece. Ron Nelson wrote a lot of pieces like this. Great to listen to, tough to play, but super exciting. Gets a listen year-round but definitely a signifier of the season. If you want another, take a listen to his "Aspen Jubilee.”
"Sleigh Ride," Leroy Anderson – I mean, do I even need to explain this one? I pull this song from my instrumental playlists until Dec. 1. This song is a must play between Dec. 1 and the 25th.
"Silent Night," The Temptations – For lots of people, it isn't Christmas until this song plays. I can't really explain it, but when I hear "In my mind..." It's officially Christmas time.
Richard Fudge
Richard Fudge, a retired teacher, led the Friend of Bob Live Music Co-op for more than 25 years.
“The Last Month of the Year,” The Staple Singers – The Staple Singers sound sublime in this call-and-response celebration of December and the birth of Jesus. The three sisters’ gorgeous gospel tones, plus a jumping band led by Pops Staples on guitar, create a thrilling jubilee.
“Run Rudolph Run,” Chuck Berry – Written, I assume, to cash in cheekily on Christmas, Chuck does a genius job of telling the story of Rudolph in an urban, modern-day setting. As usual, Chuck’s lyrics conjure vivid pictures, and his guitar playing is the essence of rock ‘n’ roll. Hilarious!
“Merry Christmas From the Family,” Robert Earl Keen – As much a short story as it is a country song, this comic masterpiece tells of a family celebrating the holiday in its idiosyncratic ways. Sharp details reveal each family members’ ordinary/extraordinary quirks. Quite sentimental, a bit like a John Prine song but slightly raunchier. Keen’s dry delivery is pitch-perfect.
Bonus cut:
“Star of Wonder,” The Roches – An a cappella gem. The Roches’ voices mesh with such lush harmony that for me this song evokes the awe of seeing that star of wonder. Sort of!
Stacy Grove
Stacy Grove is a local Realtor. “Growing up in West Lafayette, I enjoyed singing in the Chamber Choir and in various musicals at Harrison High School, under the direction of Mr. Joseph Barnard. I also had the honor of singing Handel's Messiah with the Bach Chorale, under the direction of Mr. William Grey. I believe Christmas music is one of the most intense sensory pieces of the holiday season.”
"Hark The Herald/It Came Upon A Midnight Clear,” Bing Crosby – A classic, by one of the Crooners, with a church-like choir backdrop. I love this version, which reminds me of the powerhouse choir I grew up listening to at Covenant Presbyterian Church in West Lafayette.
Literally any song on the "A Charlie Brown Christmas" album, Vince Guaraldi Trio – I mean, those guys can drop a beat. There's no way you're not toe-tappin' to nearly every song. I love the whimsey.
"Mary, Did You Know?” Pentatonix – I can't think of one time I listened to this song and didn't get chills. Not only is it masterful musically speaking (the most insane a capella arrangements!), but the story line is also one I grapple with. Did she know?
Matt Conaway
Matt Conaway is a professor of bands at Purdue University, a composer and arranger of band music, and the conductor of the Lafayette Citizens Band.
“Somewhere In My Memory,” John Williams; from the “Home Alone” soundtrack – This song is one of my favorite holiday pieces; it captures all the nostalgia of the season, but done in a more modern way through the lens of a legendary film composer.
“Mary, Did You Know” recorded by Voctave – Voctave is one of the finest a capella recording groups ever. While the text’s quality has been debated, the music itself is stellar, and Voctave has given this song the royal treatment.
“I Want A Hippopotamus For Christmas,” Gayla Peevey – The song is ridiculous; it’s an earworm that won’t go away. It’s on this list purely because it makes my partner and I laugh every time it comes on, and that’s good enough to add it to this holiday playlist!
Patrick Brown
From Patrick Brown: “I am a local musician (guitarist, producer, songwriter, composer) known for Three Cities, bndnm gnr8r and collaborating with local creators to provide arrangements, compositions and recordings for projects ranging from singles to short films. Most recently, I worked with local musicians and Rec Room Recording (TAF) to produce and record a wall of sound-style version of my opening song suggestion, “Christmas Card from a Hooker in Minneapolis” by Tom Waits (releasing 12/6).
"Christmas Card from a Hooker in Minneapolis," Tom Waits – I remember hearing this song for the first time casually flipping channels as a teenager and stumbling across Austin City Limits -- I saw this lone man sitting at a piano singing with cookie monster vocals, and while I didn't quite "get it" at the time, there was something so sincere and heartfelt about the delivery that I couldn't help being mesmerized. Years later, this song still gets me every time with its lyrics about the writers need to keep up appearances around the holidays.
"Come on Christmas," Auralnauts and Willeson – For anyone familiar with Auralnauts' work in masterfully re-editing and overdubbing the entire Star Wars saga into a ‘90s high school comedy where the party boy Jedi keep crashing the legitimate businesses of humble galactic entrepreneur Palpatine, you might be surprised to know they also put out one of the top high-energy Christmas party bops of the last two years. The resounding lyrical theme of "come on, come on Christmas" draws us ever deeper into a whirlwind of holiday cheer and shoegaze deadpan.
"We Wish You a Merry Christmas," The Craig Gildner Sextet and Tony Liberto – A holiday classic played in a classic way. I first heard this version at the end of the Hawkeye Disney+ series and was immediately transported to an Olive Garden in the North Pole. Grab yourself a cocktail and some unlimited soups, it's time to celebrate the holidays!
Dave Samuelson
Currently living in Flora, Dave Samuelson is an award-winning music historian and one of five rotating hosts on WBAA’s Acoustic Blend. His most recent reissue project is “The Lonesome Train: A Lincoln Cantata,” a 1944 ballad opera by Millard Lampell and Earl Robinson. Initially broadcast on CBS Radio, its cast members included Robinson, Burl Ives and Pvt. Peter Seeger. He also annotated “A Rootin’ Tootin’ Santa: A Hillbilly Christmas” (RWA Archives), an anthology of seasonal country and western records from the ‘40s into the ‘60s.
“Beautiful Star of Bethlehem,” The Stanley Brothers – R. Fisher Boyce didn’t have Christmas in mind when he penned “Beautiful Star of Bethlehem” in 1938. It first appeared in a 1940 songbook, but the song didn’t gain traction until the Stanley Brothers and George Shuffler recorded it for their 1964 King album “Hymns from the Cross.” Since then, it’s become a bluegrass and country Christmas standard, covered by Emmylou Harris, Patty Loveless, Larry Sparks, the Oak Ridge Boys and the Judds, among others.
“Dance of the Mirlitons,” The Nashville Mandolin Ensemble – During the late 19th century, amateur mandolin orchestras proliferated in communities across the United States. Bluegrass mandolinist Butch Baldassari assembled his 11-piece Nashville Mandolin Ensemble in homage to those seldom-recorded orchestras. Never intended to be a self-supporting enterprise, Baldassari was astounded when Columbia Records approached him in 1996, offering the ensemble $60,000 for a Christmas album. Usually performed on flutes, “Dance of the Mirlitons” appears in Act II of Tchaikovsky’s The Nutcracker Suite. (“Gifts” closes with a memorable, jazzy version of Leroy Anderson’s “Sleigh Ride.”)
“Please Come Home for Christmas,” Charles Brown – Once a major postwar figure in rhythm and blues, Charles Brown was out of popular favor by 1960. His cool, smoky style simply couldn’t compete with the era’s blistering Chicago blues, raucous rock-and-roll and dreamy doo-wop harmonies. Since his name still held some marquee value among older listeners, Cincinnati’s King Records signed him for an album of Christmas songs. The standout track, Brown’s “Please Come Home for Christmas” was released as a single and became a seasonal standard, selling a million copies by 1968. The Eagles covered the song in 1978, just as Brown was at the cusp of an enduring career renaissance.
Barrett Myers
Barrett Myers is a monthly host of Acoustic Blend on WBAA, which airs Saturday evenings at 8 p.m. on AM 920 and wbaa.org. These selections are from past episodes, and playlists are available at barrett.substack.com.
“The Holly and the Ivy", George Winston from “December” – George Winston is the perfect mood for me for a cold winter's day, and his December album is a classic. I am not yet ready for snow this winter, but I am ready for some George Winston.
"Mvmt II, Begin and Never Cease," The Oh Hellos from The Oh Hellos Family Christmas – The Oh Hellos Family Christmas is one of my favorite Christmas albums: joyful, fun and unexpected, with lots of banjo. I love how the movements flow together, making this a giant medley of favorite Christmas tunes.
"I Heard The Bells on Christmas Day," Jess Ray, Langdon – This is a beautiful arrangement of one of my favorite Christmas carols, based on the 1863 poem by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. That was written during the Civil War, and the words have buoyed me in our current hour.
Molly Birt
Molly Birt is a veterinary nursing instructional technologist at Purdue’s College of Veterinary Medicine. From Birt: “I have an eclectic taste in music, but my roots are in bluegrass and Americana folk. Choosing three songs was a tough assignment.”
"December Song," Birdtalker and Joy Williams – Following the natural cycle of the seasons has been one way to combat the sads during the darkest time of the year ... and honoring the coziness that comes with hibernation. This tune is part of that long list of songs that represent that.
"Christmas Lullaby," Doc Watson – Aoife O'Donovan has an amazing cover, but I've not been able to track it down. In any case, Doc Watson's deep voice honors the Appalachian roots of the song, and reminds me of the safety of my dad and mom when I was a half pint.
"Oi to the World," No Doubt -- … or the Vandals, heh. Your choice. We just need to peace on earth, man.
Mike Shamus
Mike Shamus is general manager at the Lafayette Media group, home of K-105, WKHY and more.
“A Marshmallow World,” Dean Martin – My Grandma Rose would ask me to sing this every year on Christmas Eve while she played the piano. She would cry the whole time, claiming, because I sang so pretty it made her weep. She was 100% Irish.
“Silent Night” – My mom's favorite.
“All I Want for Christmas is Cheese” – Hopefully I won't get nailed for picking this one. I wrote this song quite a few years ago, and we have been playing it on K-105 ever since. We put it on a CD and sold 1,000 copies, with the money going to Riley Hospital for Children. I still smile every time someone brings up the song to me and, yes, it's the only good song I have ever written.
Rick Thomas
Rick Thomas is a retired professor of Design, Art and Performance at Purdue where he has created over a dozen new original works, including “Entropics,” which premiered at Theatre Wit in Chicago last May, composed scores for over 100 productions, and led the creation of dozens of radio dramas in the long running WBAA series, “A Theatre in Your Head.”
“I’ll Be Home for Christmas,” Bing Crosby – One of the most emotionally moving songs in the history of music, “I’ll Be Home for Christmas” touched the hearts and souls of a whole generation of families separated from their children across an ocean in 1945 during World War II. It still touches our hearts in this modern world where families have increasingly become separated geographically.
“Santa Baby,” Me First and the Gimme Gimmes – Dedicated to Tim Brouk, a backbone of the local punk community for as long as anyone can remember. There’s no dearth of punk band covers of Christmas tunes, but if you’ve never heard Me First and the Gimme Gimmes, you’re in for a treat. They exclusively do punk covers of classis tunes such as “Over the Rainbow” and “Country Roads.” Made up of members of other legendary bands, from the Ramones to Foo Fighters, they’re even a better treat live.
“The Twelve Days of Christmas” – The overture from my score to “Twelfth Night” for the 1994 Colorado Shakespeare Festival. I composed and performed this variation on the “Twelve Days of Christmas” in the style of Gilbert and Sullivan in MOTU’s Digital Performer sequencer using Kurzweil 1200 Pro and Roland MT32 synth modules. Silly, bombastic and a very short one minute and thirty-three seconds of holiday fun.
John Hughey
John Hughey is executive director of the Long Center for the Performing Arts in downtown Lafayette.
“You’re A Mean One, Mr. Grinch,” Lindsey Stirling and Ashley McBryde version – The 1966 “How the Grinch Stole Christmas” has always been my favorite TV special, a staple growing up in the ‘80s. Naturally, when my two favorite badass artists teamed up for last year’s CMA Country TV special, I was smitten. Lindsey plays electric violin and is a phenom. I’ve seen her a half dozen times in concert. No one else combines trapeze artistry while playing the violin. Then, add Ashley McBryde’s gritty vocals and the Grinch is in trouble for sure. Yes, I’m also a bit biased since we’re bringing Ashley to the Long Center Jan. 30.
“Sleigh Ride,” Harry Connick, Jr. – My sister gave me “When My Heart Finds Christmas" CD when it came out in 1993. At the time, Connick’s version of “Sleigh Ride” sounded both contemporary and a throwback to me. Ever since Julie gave me that CD, it has been a part of my Christmas playlist. We're Harry Connick Jr. fans and got to see him live during his 1996 tour when he stopped at IU Auditorium.
“Sugar and Booze,” Ana Gasteyer – Saturday Night Live has been one of my all-time favorite TV shows. I love Ana Gasteyer’s holiday sketches (her portrayal of Martha Stewart and the infamous Schweddy Balls with Alec Baldwin). Of course, I absolutely love her swingin’ holiday album released in 2019. “Sugar and Booze” is my new holiday classic. It sums up how I feel once we get to the middle of December, a little punch-drunk from all the craziness.
Kevin O'Shea
Not the football coach, but another Kevin O'Shea.
“Christmas Song,” Phoebe Bridgers – Phoebe Bridgers, the millennial queen of heartbreak, teams up with Jackson Browne to cover McCarthy Trenching's “Christmas Song.” Opening with a soft, jangly piano and the haunting line, “You don’t have to be alone to be lonesome,” Bridgers gradually layers choral harmonies and jingle bells, delivering a gut-wrenching reminder that holiday sadness can hit like a brick through a window.
“River,” Joni Mitchell – A classic breakup ballad turned modern sad Christmas carol. Mitchell reflects on a Christmastime heartbreak, with a piano undertone subtly nodding to “Jingle Bells.” Perfect for belting out during solo car rides when no one’s around to hear.
“This is the New Year,” Death Cab for Cutie – The ultimate elder emo anthem for 12:01 a.m. on New Year’s Day from 2003. Opening with a wave of somber power chords, it sets the tone with the line: “So this is the new year, and I don’t feel any different.” The song captures the anxiety of unmet expectations and the weight of resolutions, like the musical equivalent of sighing and asking, “Now what?”
Kyle Brown
Kyle Brown is an ABA therapist by day and active in multiple facets at Civic Theatre of Greater Lafayette from acting, singing, writing, directing and all the odd jobs in between.
“I Wish It Was Christmas Today / Christmas Treat,” Julian Casablancas – I remember first hearing this on Saturday Night Live with Horatio Sans, Jimmy Fallon, Chris Kattan and Tracy Morgan. Julian Casablancas of The Strokes re-made it a few years later with a little extra punch and seriousness.
“Fairytale of New York,” The Pogues – I think as I grow older, the standard Christmas songs just don’t have the luster and captivation they once had. I think this song shows a wide range of music emotion that evokes a sense of the holidays not always being merry and bright for everyone.
“Christmas in Hollis,” Run-DMC – This song plays in the best Christmas movie of all time … “Die Hard.” Christmas music should all include lines about all the food you intend to eat and how much money Santa carries in his wallet.
Juanita Crider
Juanita Crider is an assistant director at the Purdue Black Cultural Center and also an instructor in the Women, Gender and Sexuality Studies program.
“Santa Claus Go Straight to the Ghetto,” James Brown – This is always the first Christmas song I play to kick off the season. It’s from his 1968 album, James Brown “Funky Christmas.” I was 7 years old in 1968 and living in Baltimore, which was one of the cities that suffered tumultuous rebellion and riots after Dr. King’s April assassination. This song was on constant rotation in my childhood home. Now as an adult and a budding American Studies scholar, I understand the intentionality of this holiday tune addressing the contemporary moment.
“What Are You Doing New Year’s Eve?” – There are many versions of this song but my favorite is by Harry Connick Jr. It’s the sentimentality and vulnerability that gets me. This song often brings me to tears. Yes, I am a hopeless romantic.
“Santa Claus is a Black Man,” Akim – This 1973 song produced by Teddy Vann is sung by his daughter Akim. She is 5 years old performing on the recording. This is still a running tease of me in my family, because as a kid when I first saw a Black Santa, I was adamant that he wasn’t Santa because Santa is white! LOLOL. I am not sure you can print this but it’s true.
Megan Mills
Megan Mills is a lifelong Lafayette local, big fan of Based in Lafayette and Christmas music. Roasts coffee for the locals and grows vegetables for her family.
“It's Christmas,” Drew Holocombe and the Neighbors – I listen to a lot of different types of Christmas music. I have multiple playlists depending on my mood. This song is on my "Christmas Struggle Bus" playlist (actual title). It's an excellent song when you are having a little trouble feeling the Christmas spirit. It's fun and relatable.
“The Rebel Jesus,” Bebo Norman – There are a lot of different versions of this song and they are all great. I think generally, people have a pretty made-up version of Jesus especially at Christmas. This song offers counter-cultural depiction of Him.
“Ceremony of Carols, Op 28: Procession: Hodie Christus Natus Est,” Lovejoy High School Varsity Women's Choir – On Christmas Eve my jam switches to "high church." The more organ and the more choral parts the better. My childhood Christmas memories were made in the church pew, hymnal in hand. Making music with others is an integral part of the joy of Christmas for me. I too sang in the Harrison choir with Stacy Grove. At every Christmas concert the girls choir lined the aisles of Graff Auditorium and filled it with this stunning piece. I love this version of high school girls choir and if you listen closely you can hear the rustle of the audience and the squeak of the chairs. As an adult, I wake up before everyone else in my house and listen to Christmas choral music in the cozy glow of the lights. If you can't hear this song live, I recommend listening in the surround sound of your car with the volume up!
Honorable Mention:
“Toy Packaging,” Sara Groves – Is this allowed? This is best for Christmas morning, when the gifts are all opened. You're exhausted and elated, surrounded by wads of wrapping paper and the real work of Christmas begins, unboxing and toy assembly.
Amy Austin
Amy Austin is a West Lafayette mom of three nearly grown kids, a snarky cocktail book author and a music lover.
“Christmas is Starting Now,” Big Bad Voodoo Daddy – My kids were obsessed with Phineas and Ferb when they were little, and this one reminds me of all the Christmas memories we cherish from when they were little.
“I Don’t Know What Christmas Is,” Old 97s – This Guardians of the Galaxy Christmas Special featured this weird one, and it became a family favorite. It’s from the perspective of aliens trying to figure out what Christmas is. And it “slaps;” I think that’s good?
“Indiana Christmas,” Straight No Chaser – I love a good song about Indiana, and this one makes me think about all the millions of hours I’ve spent on 65 driving back home to Valpo during the holidays.
Tom McCool
Tom McCool is a retired marketing and PR exec currently teaching communication classes part-time at Ivy Tech. He’s a big Rolling Stones fan and collects vinyl records.
“Hey Santa,” Chuck Leavell – Chuck was a member of the Allman Brothers Band, has led his own bands, and records and tours with The Rolling Stones when he’s not running his tree farm in Georgia. In 1998 he released a CD of R&B Christmas songs and piano instrumentals. This rollicking, fun boogie is about waiting for that present that’s high on your list.
“Cry of a Tiny Babe,” Bruce Cockburn – Bruce is a Canadian singer/songwriter who has been recording for five decades. His take on the Christmas story is both funny and moving.
“Lonely Without You (This Christmas),” Mick Jagger and Joss Stone – Mick Jagger and David Stewart wrote this for the soundtrack of the 2004 remake of “Alfie.” Mick and Joss Stone duet on a bluesy ballad that unfortunately clocks in at 2:35, fading out just when it hits a peak.
Claire Tchoula
Claire "Sheeza" Tchoula is a local rock and soul musician with top Christmas tunes to match.
“Joy,” Whitney Houston, with the Georgia Mass Choir – In my family, pressing play on "The Preacher's Wife" soundtrack by Whitney Houston (and its wonderful film) definitely marks the beginning of the holidays. The entire album is a personal favorite, but, when limited to one choice, I choose "Joy" for its jubilance. Accompanied by the Georgia Mass Choir, Whitney Houston sets a delightful tone for the season with this record.
“The Day that Love Began,” Stevie Wonder – Stevie Wonder knocked it out of the North Pole with his entire "Someday at Christmas" album. However, "The Day that Love Began" is my top track. Always enchanting, Stevie Wonder depicts a heartfelt story of a shepherd's journey to bring a gift to the newborn Christ. This beautiful story of ambition and grace resonated with me, even as a child, and still brings tears to my eyes with its evocative, reflective, and powerful music and lyrics.
“Carol of the Bells” – With so many variations and not-a-one that disappoints, "Carol of the Bells" absolutely rocks! You can light up my Christmas tree to any version, just turn it up to 11!
Honorable mention to an unforgettable voice that warms you up like a chestnut. Nat King Cole's "Christmas Song," is my favorite rendition of this comforting classic.
Charity Hendress
Charity Hendress is a piano teacher, voracious reader, extroverted introvert and a lover of all things ‘90s and 2000s music. She says: “Asking a musician to pick their favorite songs is akin to that of Sophie's choice. So in the spirit of 2024, I have picked three songs from different Eras of my life.”
“Christmas Time is Here,” Vince Guaraldi Trio – My Childhood Era: I grew up on a farm, next door to my grandparents, so we were exceptionally close. My grandma introduced me to Charlie Brown and the gang, and I'm happy to say I have shared that love with my nephews. This song feels like a hug in music form and makes me miss my grandparents (but in a good way).
“Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays,” NSYNC – My Teenage Era: I am a proud elder Millennial. My love for NSYNC will never die, they show up on my Spotify wrapped every year. This song instantly puts a smile on my face and makes me want to dance around.
“O Come, O Come Emmanuel,” instrumental version, Casting Crowns – My Adult Era: A few years ago we did a Bible study at my church based upon the verse in Isaiah 7:14. We listened to numerous versions of this song, but this version is still hands down my favorite. The layers of emotions that are brought out through the various instruments take you on a journey.
It feels illegal not to mention “Christmas Tree Farm” by Taylor Swift, given that we went through the eras of my life.
Stacey Mickelbart
Stacey Mickelbart is a writer and editor for Purdue Agriculture, music lover and fan of Greater Lafayette’s arts organizations, including the Lafayette Symphony Orchestra, where she serves as president of the board of directors.
“Suite from the Polar Express,” Alan Silvestri – This song has so many elements of a good holiday tune: notes that glisten and sparkle like snowfall, bells and soaring strings, and the hopeful energy of a choir. If this movie or soundtrack is one of your favorites, you can enjoy hearing it and other holiday classics at the Lafayette Symphony Orchestra’s Holiday Pops concert this Saturday, Dec. 14, at 7:30 pm at Long Center.
“White Christmas,” V of BTS and Bing Crosby – When Bing Crosby’s estate found out that V, the jazziest member of powerhouse Korean group BTS, loved Crosby’s music, they reached out to see if V would like to duet. Using a 1950s radio recording from the Crosby archive as the starting point, technology merged new instrumentation and V’s rich, caramel harmonies to honor this classic – with a twist!
“First Snowfall,” Michael W. Smith – While we often think of festive social and family gatherings during winter holidays, the season also provides quiet moments for rest and introspection. If I were soundtracking the movie of life, this song plays while I’m staring out at the snowflakes falling, cozy inside, planning to take on a new year.
Troy Kult
Troy Kult goes by DJ Circle T. He says he’ll be playing these outside the Lafayette Theater this Saturday for A Merry Main Street Market.
“Father Christmas,” Kinks – I like the more rock n roll, nontraditional Christmas songs, and this one fits the bill! Some interesting lyrics in there.
“Run Rudolph Run,” Chuck Berry – Fun rock n roll feel-good jam that's always a hit with almost everyone.
“Blue Xmas (To Whom It May Concern),” Miles Davis – This one is on a cassette tape called Holiday Jazz I found at Goodwill a few years back. Commentary by Bob Dorough (lyrics and vocals) this one sums up the bah hum bug many feel around Christmas time. Not a feel good jam.
Andrea Bube
From Andrea Bube: “I'm a ‘transplant’ to the Greater Lafayette area. I moved here in 2006 when I was hired as the choir director at East Tipp Middle School and have been honored to work with the students there since then. I've had the pleasure of singing with professional choirs in Indiana and Kentucky and enjoy performing as a guest vocalist whenever needed.”
“Peace on Earth/Little Drummer Boy,” Bing Crosby and David Bowie – Bing is best known for his “White Christmas,” but this one ranks higher in my heart. I remember listening to it with my Granny while we decorated her house. We'd often sing along to it ... she was Bing, I was Bowie.
“White Winter Hymnal,” Pentatonix – The sweet harmonies of Pentatonix AND amazing body percussion?! I'm so in!
“Underneath the Tree,” Kelly Clarkson – I adore Kelly Clarkson! To me, this is the perfect Christmas love song. Upbeat, optimistic and when the tubular bells kick in in the middle of the song, you can't help but dance a little.
Karl Brandt
Karl Brandt is a long-time member of the Lafayette Master Chorale (née Bach Chorale Singers), and years-ago (when he was younger) performer in Civic Theatre musicals.
“There Shall a Star from Jacob Come Forth,” (Chorus), Felix Mendelssohn – There is a nice recording by The Washington Chorus. The Lafayette Master Chorale will be performing it at our Family Carols concert at 2 and 4:30 p.m. Dec. 15 at First Baptist Church in Lafayette.
“The Dream Isaiah Saw” by Thomas Troeger (words) & Glenn L. Rudolph (music) – Again, there is a nice recording by The Washington Chorus. And again, it will be performed by the Lafayette Master Chorale at our Family Carols program this year.
“A Child’s Christmas in Wales” by Dylan Thomas, read by Dylan Thomas – This is not a carol, nor a poem, but a beautiful story written and read poetically by the author himself, bringing the poetry of the prose alive for the listener.
Angela Vinson
Angela Vinson is a local Artist and other artists cheerleader. When she is not making art or running LaLaGallery.com or IndianaMakersMarket.com – catch the third and final weekend Friday-Sunday, Dec. 13-15, at Wea Creek Orchard – or BinderyArtistStudios.com she is spending time with her dogs #LaLasZero and #LaLasDean, gardening and collecting seeds, and eating cake.
"Is It Christmas Tonight,” J. Roddy Walston – When the whole world shut down, artists and makers had to get creative and find new ways to connect to their audience. J. Roddy masked up and pulled off a Christmas Special that streamed live, and gave myself and others a new way to celebrate. It is so inspiring to see artists flex and collaborate. I stream the whole playlist during the holidays to get through the makers grind!
“Smokestacks,” Layla – My grandfather passed away on Dec. 11, 2015. I was working on a playlist for the Indiana Makers Market and this song came across my desk. Although it is about passion and desire and can be romantic, I relate it to my grandpa's death and the lyrics hit me so differently. He was a heavy smoker, I was covered in jet black from mourning, and he was carried home. We played it at his funeral and the passion in the song describes the feeling of loss and love for my grandfather. It brings me happiness to hear it on a cold December day.
"Christmas in Hollis,” Run D.M.C. – You know some Christmas songs on the radio start to grate your nerves, just me? “Christmas in Hollis” is never skipped when it is on the air, and is purposely added to playlists at the pop-ups and shop.
Andrew Milam
I’m Andrew Milam, a technology director by day and musician by night. I play keyboards in The Groove, a local cover band and am the proud father of my daughter and son, who are both students at Purdue University. Music, family and friends are at the heart of my holiday traditions.
“That Spirit of Christmas,” Ray Charles – This soulful classic immediately transports me to the heartwarming scene in National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation when Clark is in the attic watching old home movies. It captures the nostalgia and magic of the holidays, reminding me of the importance of family and cherished memories.
“Happy Xmas (War Is Over),” John Lennon and Yoko Ono – This timeless anthem blends the holiday spirit with a powerful message of peace. It’s a song that encourages reflection and hope for a better world, making it a must-have for any holiday playlist.
“Linus and Lucy,” Vince Guaraldi Trio – This jazzy instrumental from “A Charlie Brown Christmas” instantly brings back memories of childhood and the joy of the season. It’s playful, heartwarming and perfectly captures the whimsy of the holidays.
Colin William
Colin William is a teaching professor in the Department of Psychological Sciences at Purdue, and these selections notwithstanding he really does enjoy the upbeat tracks at the holidays as well.
“Grateful for Christmas,” Hayes Carll – Beautifully captures how the experience of Christmas changes as we age, from the larger-than-life Christmases of childhood to the small-as-life Christmases of adulthood. Wistful and real at the same time.
“Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas,” Norah Jones and Laufey – A wonderful duet, with Jones and Laufey complementing each other both in voice and through instruments. And, thankfully, they went with the correct lyric – sorry, Sinatra, you may have been The Chairman of the Board, but "Hang a shining star upon the highest bough" remains a crime against the more human sentiment of the original "Until then we'll have to muddle through somehow."
“Fairytale of New York,” Florence + the Machine and Billy Bragg – We shall stipulate for the record that nobody can top The Pogues' and Kirsty MacColl's original on this one, but this cover is pretty in its own right, with two distinctive voices in Florence Welsh and Billy Bragg and the harp to really distinguish it from the original. As an immigrant whose parents struggled here in the United States, Fairytale resonates with me with its themes of big dreams dashed by harsh reality and human frailty. Yet, there's just that little glimmer of hope at the end ...
Kelly Kerns
In her own words: “My name is Kelly Kerns, and I am an English teacher at Lafayette Jeff. This year I began my 25th year teaching there. I am also an avid music fan, but my tastes don't usually run along the lines of Christmas music and carols. To be honest, most of them get on my nerves. Bah, Humbug! However, there are exceptions to every rule, just as in grammar and spelling, and these are my exceptions.”
"Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas," Judy Garland – From one of my favorite movies, “Meet Me in St. Louis,” this song gets me every time. Sung by Garland to a very upset Margaret O'Brien in an effort to comfort her because the family will soon be leaving St. Louis to move to New York City, this version pulls on my heartstrings whenever I hear it. My dad moved our family around when I was a kid, and the plaintiveness in Garland's voice perfectly expresses the uncertainty I felt as a child. In the film, the dad ends up keeping his family in St. Louis, maybe because of Garland's wistful rendition of this tune.
"Christmas," The Who – I'll be the first to admit this is an odd choice. In this track from the album “Tommy,” arguably the first "rock opera," the Who lament the fact that Tommy, who is deaf, mute, and blind, cannot enjoy Christmas morning like the other kids do. Punctuated throughout with Roger Daltrey's roaring "yeahs" and Keith Moon's tight drum fills, this song rocks. Throwing into the lyrics the familiar nostalgia of kids waiting to see their presents on Christmas morning makes this a true Christmas song in my book.
"The Twelve Days of Christmas," Bob & Doug McKenzie (aka Rick Moranis and Dave Thomas) – Who doesn't love a silly Christmas song? You can't get much sillier than this gem! Liberally sprinkled with Canadianisms, it cracks me up every time. This song taught me what a "toque" is (a knitted beanie) and introduced me to the term "hoser." "The Twelve Days of Christmas" makes me want to move to the Great White North so I can get a toque, French toast, and four pounds of back bacon from my true love, not to mention that beer ... in a tree.
Penny Keller
In her own words: “I grew up in the area but moved to Florida and spent 24 years there before moving back for family. I’m now involved with the Art Museum as a board member and chair of their Heart of Art fundraiser, along with other community activities.”
“Mistletoe Mambo,” Michael Andrew and Swingerhead – Living in Florida I saw him numerous times for his holiday performance. This song is such a fun and jazzy holiday song. And why wouldn’t you want to kiss your sweetie after hearing this?
“Santa Baby,” Eartha Kitt – Just a fun song. She’s so sassy. What’s not to like about Eartha Kitt!
“The Holidaze,” Sara Melson – She’s a West Lafayette native, and I came to know her music
Larry Sommers
Larry Sommers is a fundraiser/marketer/administrator who serves as chief development officer for Food Finders Food Bank and has lived in the Lafayette community for over 30 years.
“Christmas Time is Here,” Diana Krall – I love her sultry, whisper-in-your-ear vocals on this melancholy Vince Guaraldi tune that most people know in its instrumental form from “A Charlie Brown Christmas.”
“Sleigh Ride,” Steve Lawrence and Eydie Gorme – I’m not sure what I like most about this throwback to the days when nightclub acts were king and everyone had a variety show – Eydie’s trumpet of a voice belting “SLEIGH RIDE SLEIGH RIDE” as a counterpoint, or the charmingly cheesy dialogue that frames the song.
“Peace on Earth/Little Drummer Boy,” Bing Crosby and David Bowie – I remember watching this weird and wonderful duet as a teenager when it originally aired in 1977, when TVs were furniture and kids were the remote controls.
Judd Danby
Judd Danby is a composer of classical and jazz works, jazz pianist and music educator who’s lived in Lafayette for over 20 years. He co-founded and served as artistic director of the Jazz Club from 2009–2018 and frequently gives pre-performance talks at Purdue Convocations.
"Dance of the Reed Flutes," from the Nutcracker Suite, as performed by the Ted Rosenthal Trio (with Noriko Ueda and Tim Horner) on their “Winter Wonderland” recording — A really fun and clever rendition of the much-loved Tchaikovsky in a playful Afro-Latin style (!) for jazz piano trio.
“Santa Claus Is Coming to Town," as performed by Joshua Redman, Brad Mehldau, Larry Grenadier, and Jorge Rossy on “Warner Bros. Jazz Christmas Party” — A seriously swingin’ version of the classic tune, filled with great improvisations and musical interactions between four top-tier jazz artists.
"God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen," as performed by Paquito D’Rivera and John Miller on Columbia Record’s “Jingle Bell Jazz” — A deeply groovin’ and very unusual take on the old carol for sax and acoustic bass duo.
Derrick Jones
Derrick Jones grew up in Springfield, Illinois, and spent 25 years in Washington, D.C. In 2020 he followed his brother (Q1067's Jim Stone) and transplanted in Lafayette. He is the founder of the marketing and consulting firm, Vine Street Creative, and the interim executive director of Pride Lafayette.
“Adeste Fideles (O Come All Ye Faithful),” Gay Men's Chorus of Washington, D.C. (featuring the Chevy Chase Bell Ringers) – Adeste is my all-time favorite. It reminds me of going to Midnight Mass with Mom and Grandma at the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception in Springfield, Illinois. And this arrangement by the Gay Men's Chorus of Washington, complete with bell ringers and the swell of the organ reminds me of that annual tradition and always brings me to tears (plus, experiencing the "wall of sound" of 250-plus voices performing this live was always a moving experience).
“(There's No Place Like) Home for Holidays,” Perry Como – My first Christmas record (actual record that I wore out on my turntable) was "Seasons Greetings from Perry Como," and "Home for the Holidays" quickly became my favorite on the album (and overall favorite holiday song, second only to Adeste). Not sure why it resonated with a 10-year-old, but I dug the jazzy sound. When I moved to D.C. at 18, the song took on a whole new meaning as I'd make the trek annually back to Illinois. And today, it's a fond reminder of my wonderful Christmas memories growing up.
“Christmas Can-Can,” Straight No Chaser – I saw SNC at the Birchmere in Arlington, Virginia, in December 2009 when they were on (what I think was) their first-ever tour (working through America's smallest venues). The arrangements. The comedy. The a capella. I was hooked, and SNC became part of my holiday soundtrack and their concerts became a holiday tradition. Now, it's not the holidays until I see the Rockettes high kick and SNC can-can.
Mark Thoennes
Mark Thoennes says: “I'm a mostly lifelong resident of Lafayette (for all but six years) graduating from Jeff and Purdue. My first job took me to Kansas City and then St. Louis, but I returned to Indiana to be closer to family and my future wife. I am now enjoying retirement after 27 years with SIA.”
“Better Without a Sweater,” Tiffany Houghton and Jay Alan – Our newest Christmas favorite is "Better Without a Sweater," a duet cowritten and sung by Jay Alan and Tiffany Houghton. Full disclosure – Jay is our youngest son. This is an incredibly fun song that always makes us smile whenever we hear it. Jay graduated from Harrison High School and the Berklee College of Music in Boston.
“Christmas Wrapping,” The Waitresses – “Christmas Wrapping" by The Waitresses always meant turning up the volume when it came on the radio in the ‘80s. The song and their video is nostalgic for that era, but I never figured out the meaning of the cobbler seemingly controlling everything. Maybe that's how she finally met up with that guy she had been chasing all year?
“Wintersong,” Sarah McLachlan – Since another reader grabbed Run DMC's "Christmas in Hollis," I will completely switch gears and go with Sarah McLachlan's "Wintersong." So many words describe her and this song – elegant, exquisite, peaceful. Listening to her begs one to sit quietly and just be.
Charles Ross
Charles Ross taught English and Comparative Literature at Purdue from 1977 to 2019.
“Silent Night” – “Silent Night is No. 1, in any version preferably with some verses in German. I love listening to the Cambridge King’s College Choir Christmas concerts, for example, “O Holy Night,” Kings College Choir. Or “O Come, All Ye Faithful,” as well as “Silent Night.”
Despite the beauty of those just mentioned, I’ll choose “O Come All Ye Faithful” as No. 2 because you can learn some Latin listening to it as “Adeste Fideles.” I remember a music book on the piano of my best friend’s house open to that title. Here’s a version by Enya.
My number three is “O Hannukah, O Hannukah.” At Montrose School, where I went to K-6 in South Orange, New Jersey, the teachers kept the Jewish students mind, too, for the annual Christmas concert. Avoid any version too jazzy or too fast or Adam Sandler. Here’s a kid-friendly recording.
Grace Wereley-Bross
Grace Wereley-Bross is a West Side graduate and current freshman in Environmental Studies at Washington University in St. Louis. She particularly enjoys classic Christmas movies in which the acting is all performed by inanimate objects.
"One More Sleep 'til Christmas," Kermit the Frog – “The Muppet Christmas Carol” is a classic and a perennial watch in the WLHS Orchestra. The joy that Kermit and the Muppets bring is contagious, and I guarantee you will feel better about humanity after a watch. This song is the best of the bunch, capturing the childhood joy of Christmas Eve.
"Blue Christmas," Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox – This song first earned a place in my heart from the delightful stop-motion Christmas special “The Year Without a Santa Claus,” but this cover by Postmodern Jukebox brings a jazzy twist. The whole album is worth a listen for its soulful vocals, tap-dance breaks and bass solos.
"Mele Kalikimaka," Geoff Castellucci, The American Sirens – A recommendation from my sibling. Castellucci is best known for singing bass in the acapella group VoicePlay, and he brings his smooth voice and impressive vocal range to all of his songs. This cover never fails to bring a smile to my face.
Jon Neal
From Jon Neal: “I have been listening to Christmas music for over 69 years. I like the edgy tunes. No snow, commercialism, sappy, politics or religion.”
“Nutttin' for Christmas,” Sid Tepper and Roy C. Bennett – In 1955, 6-year-old Barry Gordon makes a Top 10 hit fronting the Art Mooney orchestra. "I'm getting nuttin' for Christmas, 'cause I ain't been nuttin' but bad." Somebody snitched on this bad boy who would rather do what he wants than be good to get presents. Take that commercialism!
“Christmas Will Really Be Christmas,” written by Ben Raleigh and J.W. Alexander – Chicago's Lou Rawls is backed by a big band in his 1967 release. "When hearts are filled with joy, instead of worry and fear. That's when the words, ‘Merry Christmas’ will be so much more sincere.” Peace, joy, happiness. What more do I need on Christmas?
“Yuletide Throwdown,” Blondie and Fab 5 Freddy – Blondie, who first brought rap to MTV, teamed up with Fab 5 Freddy for this 1981 hip hop rap throwdown. "Well it's on and on and on, on and on Christmas rapping to the break of dawn." Ain't the wack! I'm a Blondie fan forever and 43 years after this dropped they are still performing.
Lynn Hooker
Lynn Hooker moved to West Lafayette in 2015 and joined the faculty of the Purdue music department. She teaches classes on music history and theory and world music. From her: “I do research on music and musicians, and I also spent years as a viola player and choral singer – so I love a lot of kinds of music, and three selections barely scratches the surface. Your challenge is hard to resist, though, so here goes!”
“Geistliches Wiegenlied” (Sacred Lullaby), Johannes Brahms – Brahms sent this lullaby to two of his friends, violinist Joseph Joachim and singer Amalie Weiss, at the time baptism of their son (named Johannes after Brahms). In the text, Mary asks Joseph to help her rock her baby to sleep. I played it at church a few months after my daughter was born. Sung by the divine Jessye Norman.
“The Virgin Mary Had a Baby Boy,” Harry Belafonte – This is a favorite from one of my college choir’s Christmas concerts but in a gentle version by the late, great Harry Belafonte. One source says that it gained wider circulation after the 92-year-old Afro-Caribbean singer James Bryce shared it with a collector in 1942; the earliest commercial recording I’ve found of this Christmas song is from 1945. You can find dozens of versions, but I like Belafonte’s the best.
“Ocho Kandelikas” (Eight Candles), Flory Jagoda – I wanted to include a Hanukkah song since my family is Jewish, and this one, by Sephardic Jewish singer Flory Jagoda and sung in Ladino (a dialect of Spanish), is super catchy – it’s a great sing-along song. I first heard her in Chicago while I was in grad school. Jagoda escaped Yugoslavia in 1941 with her parents at the time of the Nazi invasion; she and her parents came to the U.S. as refugees, but most of the rest of her family and community were killed during the war. She first became widely known for singing her grandmother’s songs from Sarajevo, but she wrote “Ocho Kandelikas,” her best known song, herself in the 1980s. She made her first recording when she was in her sixties, so it gives me hope that I can continue being creative as I get older.
David Corley
David Corley is a Lafayette musician. Treat yourself and listen to the “Available Light” and “Zero Moon” albums.
“Christmas Card From A Hooker In Minneapolis,” Tom Waits – A heartfelt/funny song about a girl writing her old dope buddy to tell him she's pregnant. She reminds him of all the crazy fun things they used to do – well, and she needs money, it's Christmas. But nothing is true. She's not pregnant. She's in prison and needs money for her lawyer because she's up for parole. Very heart-rending holiday song.
“Remember (Christmas),” Harry Nilsson – Another beautiful song from Harry. Tugs on the heartstrings.
“Christmas All Over Again,” Tom Petty – So fun to hear Tom's distinct voice on a Christmas tune. The Heartbreakers make it all fun again.
Arnold Chen
From Arnold Chen: “I grew up in West Lafayette in the ‘70s and ‘80s. Moved to California after college eventually settling in the San Francisco Bay area. In 2015 we moved our family back to West Lafayette where my kids will be second generation Red Devils. am currently teaching at Purdue and also serve on the West Lafayette Redevelopment Commission.”
“7 O'Clock News/Silent Night,” Simon & Garfunkel – I fell in love with Simon & Garfunkel in college and was stunned when I first heard this on the “Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme” album. I'm not sure I've ever heard this on the radio.
“Peace on Earth/Little Drummer Boy,” Bing Crosby and David Bowie – Love the contrast between two singers who you wouldn't think would collaborate. When David Bowie first sings "Peace on Earth," it always gives me goose bumps
“Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer,” Gene Autry – Brings me back to my childhood of image of a warm house with the family cozied up on the couch waiting for the public broadcast. "It's on…"
Jessica Jaques Collaço
In her own words: “I’m an independent singer/songwriter and love finding unexpected cuts and artists to share with friends (and for them to share with me). In searching for unique songs to sing, I tend to come across (and compose) selections that you might not hear on your typical holiday list.”
“Cold, Hot Cocoa Evening,” Hayek and Young – Hayek and Young bring some funk to the party. Based in SoCal, you can hear the jazz influence mixed with the earthy festival vibe that makes you feel like you might be enjoying hot cocoa under a starry desert sky.
“Savior,” Jessica Collaço – Holidays aren’t always easy or welcome, especially when a person is grieving. I wrote a song to acknowledge that and let people know that they aren’t alone, even on the darkest nights.
“The Wonder Song,” Indigo Girls – For days when you need to clean up the house or bake goodies for the guests, a jaunty bluegrass tune can fend off the gloomy skies. The Indigo Girls bring pleasant harmonies, banjo and a quick tempo, making it easy to get up and get going, or at least tap your toes.
Sean Sullivan
In his words: “A 40-year transplant, landscape designer, horticulturalist, married to Karen, head horticulturist at the Jules Janick Botanic Garden at Purdue University (gee, guess what we do in our spare time); sons Conor and Patrick living in Chicago. Interests include college hoops and a fascination and interest in how our community continues to grow and evolve.”
“The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire),” Johnny Mathis – Growing up in the Sullivan house, it was the first song my Mother Bonnie would want to hear when the Christmas season kicked off. The album cover with Johnny, his skis and all that fake snow is burned in my memory.
“Boots,” The Killers – A more current Christmas tune takes me back to Christmas in home town of Valparaiso. There is a place in the house I grew up in where I could see my mother in the kitchen, father on the floor watching television, “It’s a Wonderful Life.” My dad introduced me to this movie. The manner in which the Killers bring the bridge scene of “It’s A Wonderful Life” into the song is genius.
“Bob’s Major Award,” from “A Christmas Story” – Sorry to go back to the Region again, but Dad was a Jean Shepard junkie. My parents both grew up in Hammond, and Dad had several Jean Shepard books. When the movie came out, it was must watch TV in the Sullivan house and has continued to be one in ours. “Bob’s Major Award” lets me know it’s time to get my annual fictionalized, but representative, look at the time period in which my parents grew up.
Larry Guentert
Larry Guentert is a local percussion instructor and a retired engineer. He plays in several local bands.
“Good King Wenceslas” and “Coventry Carol,” Loreena McKennitt – These are by Canadian musician Loreena McKennitt, who has strong Celtic and world music influences. Her songs all have Irish flute, harp, bagpipes and more, supporting her gorgeous vocals which float over mesmerizing Celtic grooves.
“I Believe in Father Christmas,” Greg Lake – By prog rocker Greg Lake, whom you may remember from the band Emerson, Lake and Palmer. Listen closely to his guitar, lush vocals and interesting lyrics in this holiday tune. This song should be on everyone's playlist.
“O Come, O Come, Immanuel,” David Friesen – Multi-instrumentalist David Friesen is mostly known for playing experimental upright bass with lots of cool effects, but on this song, he plays the flute.
Loran Parker
In her own words: “I am a transplant from South Bend who arrived in West Lafayette 25 years ago for a Purdue education and fell in love with Greater Lafayette. My husband and I are raising our two children here, and I am a research scholar in Purdue's College of Education. About my selections: I attended the only private, non-religious K-8 school in South Bend. As such, it was a school rich in cultural and religious diversity – not unlike Greater Lafayette. We spent time every December celebrating the traditions of the various families that made up our school community. Even though I was raised Presbyterian, I really enjoyed getting to learn about and celebrate a wide array of traditions every year. I thought I would add some of my favorite Hanukkah songs to our list.”
“The Chanukkah Song,” Adam Sandler – As an Xennial, this song is seared into my brain. I cannot enter December without singing it and smiling.
“Hanukkah Blessings,” Barenaked Ladies – Who knew the Barenaked Ladies had a holiday album!? Now you do.
“8 Days (of Hanukkah),” Sharon Jones and the Dap Kings – The late, great Sharon Jones produced some of the best soul music of the past few decades. She and the Dap Kings bring their best soul to this school-house rock style jingle.
Mike Smith
From your friendly county election board staffer and keeper of election minutia in Tippecanoe County.
"Go Tell It on the Mountain,” Janice Harrington – Janice Harrington is a jazz and blues goddess who got her start in the ‘60s in USO shows. She still performs in her 80s. This song is from her “Christmas in New Orleans” album and also features her husband – the great jazz trombonist Werner Gürtler – and her best friend Linda Fields.
“Carol of the Bells/We Three Kings,” Scott Bradlee – Scott Bradlee puts together a great medley/mash up in his Post Modern Jukebox-style Christmas piano solo. Whenever I hear this I smile, as it reminds me of the fun and innovative orchestra teacher I had, the fantastic Jeff Boswell. Mr. Boswell not only taught the technique and theory of music, but the joy, satisfaction and pure unadulterated fun of making music, like the founder of Post Modern Jukebox, Scott Bradlee.
“A Christmas Festival,” Boston Pops with Arthur Fiedler conducting – This version has the swelling 4800 pipe Aeolian-Skinner organ of Boston Symphony Hall taking the nine-minute medley to beat all Christmas medleys to a rousing crescendo finish. The Boston organ was just a year old that time, and the composer/arranger, the famed Leroy Anderson, was on hand to insist upon its use as they recorded the performance for RCA Records. The original recording was a 78 single, with half of the medley on one side, half on the other because a 78 record was limited to about eight minutes of play to a side.
Shirley Reynolds
In her words: “I grew up on Stillwell Street in Lafayette, graduated from Jeff in 1960 and from Purdue in January 1966. I worked as a speech/language pathologist in TSC for 3½ years, then moved to Racine, Wisconsin, where I worked in the school district for another 40½ years. I raised my daughter here on the shores of Lake Michigan and have found many wonderful friends here. It's been a good place to live, but I still miss things about Lafayette and West Lafayette: My sisters and some friends, Arni's, Triple XXX, Von's and close access to the campus.”
“I Heard the Bells on Christmas Day,” Harry Belafonte – I first heard this song in the early-‘60s and it resonated with the struggle for civil rights that was happening at the time. I was a student at Purdue then and marching around the courthouse with others when some of the students were killed in the South. Unfortunately, the words are still relevant today.
“Silver Bells,” Doris Day – I have a great memory of doing my Christmas shopping around the square downtown in the evening about 64 years ago. It was snowing and this song was playing on the loudspeaker outside, the lights were strung from the dome of the court house to each of the four corners, and it was a festive time.
“The Christmas Song,” Mel Torme – A cozy nostalgic song that he sings in his smooth voice. If we don't have snow, this song puts me in the Christmas mood immediately.
Lyle Janney
You may have seen Lyle Janney involved with various theater productions in Greater Lafayette over the past decade or more, or more recently as Mr. Fezziwig in “A Christmas Carol” at the Delphi Opera House. He came to the Greater Lafayette area in the early 1980s as a student at Purdue University. He has been a Purdue employee in Student Systems (IT) for nearly 28 years.
“Father Christmas,” The Kinks – Things are not all “sugar plums and roses” for military families, as much today as in the ‘60s and ‘70s. Sometimes Christmas comes after the 25th and is more about the socks, coat and scarf than the toys. This song wrapped up my youthful angst into a solid nugget that would let me feel better about my lot in life, all things considered.
“Fairytale of New York,” The Pogues – A decade after that first song, along came Irish punk to put another spin on the holiday. I was at Purdue, out on my own, and struggling to figure out how to overcome the toxicity of the environment I grew up in. Yes, this one is dirty and gritty, but it is also supportive and educational once you figure out what to look for.
“Little Drummer Boy/Peace On Earth,” Bing Crosby and David Bowie – Eventually, I would return to my roots. My taste in music has always been eclectic, and there are few other pairings more diametric than this one. For me, it’s just not Christmas until I hear Bing’s crooning basso alongside Bowie’s ethereal notes. I’d rather catch it “in the wild,” but if I haven’t by the 23rd, I’ll pull it up myself. Enjoy and Blessed Yule!
Phillip Fiorini
From Phillip Fiorini: “Too many from which to choose, but here’s a narrowed threesome.”
“Hey Guys! It’s Christmas Time,” Sufjan Stevens – All things Sufjan can’t be beat. But the Alt Indie musician’s Christmas boxed set of mostly original songs is a winner. Tough to pick my favorite, but the kids loved this one first, it’s ebb and flow personality with Sufjan’s vintage ballad sound and a touch of heavy metal t beat. Just to get the four-album set started and let it roll. On Christmas or the days leading up to our family celebration.
“Christmas All Over Again,” Tom Petty – Love Petty and miss the music he could’ve created. Thankfully, he gave us this winner for Christmas. This is a fun rocker that seems to sneak into more and more Christmas movies – “Home Alone 2” (played appropriately as Mom and Dad aboard the plane discover Kevin getting left behind — again), as well as “Jingle All The Way” and “Four Christmases.”
“Christmas in New Orleans,” Louis Armstrong – Can’t have a true Christmas without a taste of holiday jazz. And this one, from Louie Armstrong, offers my soul the sweet sound of the trumpet (our son Andrew’s instrument) in its grand Big Band setting. A classic for all time.
Brad Cohen
From Brad Cohen, an owner of Arni’s Restaurants: “I may have the largest collection of Christmas albums for anyone, but especially for someone who is Jewish! I will be caught playing Christmas tunes in July, just for the smile it creates in all of us! I have often said that it is too bad we all don’t have the ‘Christmas Spirit’ all year every year! I tend to find my inspiration on the jazzier or bluesier styles. Virtually impossible to pick just three, but here are a few of my favs!”
“Five Pound Box of Money,” Pearl Bailey – No one sings it better than Pearl.
“Cool Yule,” Louis Armstrong – Appropriately named, too Cool!
“Santa Claus is Coming to Town,” Bruce Springsteen – Fun, lively, real, as you would expect from The Boss!
Larry DeBoer
In his own words: “I was a professor of agricultural economics at Purdue for 37 years until I retired in 2021. I did a lot of extension work too, about state and local government policy, especially property taxes. Looks like that’ll be a hot topic once again in 2025. I still live in West Lafayette with my wife Melody and daughter Caroline. Son Will is off in Maryland with wife Keirsten and our first granddaughter, Blair.”
“Little Road to Bethlehem,” Shawn Colvin – A lovely voice, great tune, acoustic arrangement, happy and cozy. It’s from a terrific Christmas album called “Holiday Songs and Lullabies.”
“Jingle Bells,” The Roches – The Roches are Maggie, Terre and Suzy Roche, and this is an a cappella version of the old song. They harmonize like the sisters they are. It’s off our family’s go-to Christmas album, “We Three Kings,” which has many more acoustic and a cappella versions of Christmas songs, including a bit of Handel’s Messiah.
“Joy to the World,” Aretha Franklin – You want joy? Here it is!
Honorable Mentions: In the spirit of Billy Mack’s “Christmas is All Around” from Love Actually:
“867-5309/Jenny (Christmas version),” Tommy Tutone – It’s “Santa Claus is Coming to Town” sung to the tune of their big ‘80s hit.
Lauren Bruce
Lauren Bruce is a West Lafayette expat living in Madison, Wisconsin. She ran the indie news site Think Lafayette through the 2010s with co-founder John Fry and a cohort of other aging hipsters, which focused on the arts, culture and people who make the Lafayette area cool, weird and wonderful.
“Christmas Rappin',” Kurtis Blow – The bass line for this classic song, which borrows from disco and early hip hop, is infectious. It takes from Queen's "Another One Bites the Dust" and tells a story about Christmas in Blow's house. It'll push through the fog of tryptophan and have your family's butts moving to the beat.
“Player's Ball,” Outkast – This classic hip hop song was on Outkast's debut album, but many don't know that it was originally released on the 1993 "A LaFace Family Christmas" album along with an array of other holiday bangers from TLC and others. It's a Christmas song – technically! – that provides a great soundtrack for when the formal celebrations are over and you're hanging out with your cousins after dinner.
“Christmas Wrapping,” The Waitresses – This classic by new wave band The Waitresses, most famous for the bratty punk favorite "I Know What Boys Like," has been covered by a dozen other artists and featured in major commercials. It's an original pop hit that illustrates the whirlwind of the holiday season in all its grandness and anxiety. Stick around for the horns.
Brian Leung
From Brian Leung, a Purdue professor of English: “I'm the author of six books of fiction, with the most recent out this January. I come from a deep background of Protestants and Catholics. I believe in live Christmas trees. Music plays almost no role in my life, but I'm totally fine if someone turns on the radio as long as they keep the sound at background level. I have deep respect for skilled musicians, but it's like how many people never read novels. That doesn't offend me, even though I'm a novelist.”
“We Need a Little Christmas,” from the “Mame” cast album (Angela Lansbury) – The song reminds us that we don't have to wait for pre-designated days to lift each other's spirits.
Vince Guaraldi's entire jazz assembly for “A Charlie Brown Christmas” – The animated special is decidedly not secular, but Guaraldi's jazz tracks make a convincing case that his music is the reason for the season – for the secular in our population.
“Kidnap the Santy Claws” and “Making Christmas,” Danny Elfman, “Nightmare Before Christmas Soundtrack” – “Kidnap the Santy Claws" is a devilish song in a devilish and delightful movie that makes one think, and laugh, about who "owns" Christmas and just now necessary Santa Claus is or is not. It's a hoot to play in the rotation when you're wrapping presents. “Making Christmas" reminds me of Charlie Chaplin's “Modern Times.” Christmas is an assembly line but maybe, just maybe an event that might deliver happiness if you do your job right. But, what is that job, exactly?
"9 to 5," Dolly Parton – Reason: When I was in seventh grade I took the county bus to the mall 40 minutes away and paid, seven times, to see the movie of the same name. When I hear that song it reminds me of what Mr. Hart would send out as Christmas cards.
Barb Knochel
In her own words: “While I was born in Lafayette, I never actually lived here until I started high school. My dad spent 20 years in the Army, and according to my mother they moved 23 times in 20 years. Being able to spend Christmas with extended family was a special treat. So many people, tons of food and great memories.”
“White Christmas,” Bing Crosby – I used to watch the movie “White Christmas” every year while I was wrapping gifts. The connection to the Korean War and soldiers made it even more special. Nothing better than Bing Crosby rich baritone voice.
“Silent Night,” Frank Sinatra – Memories of attending church on Christmas Eve, holding candles and gathering in the front of the church. The lights in the church were dimmed and everyone sang “Silent Night.” I can also remember learning how to sing it in German when we lived overseas. Brought memories of the true meaning of Christmas wherever you were.
“Little Drummer Boy,” Pentatonix – The beautiful blending of voices tells a wonderful story. Mesmerizing to listen to.
Vincent Walter
Vincent Walter is a photographer in Lafayette.
“Must Be Santa,” Mitch Miller – I lost both my parents last year. My mother used to put three or four albums on her GE console stereo during this holiday season: Johnny Mathis, Harry Simeone’s “Little Drummer Boy,” Andy Williams, and Mitch Miller’s “Holiday Sing-Along.” As years went by and she accumulated compact disks, Mitch Miller fell out of rotation. The songs on Mitch Miller’s album, particularly “Must be Santa,” are powerful ear-worms. They take me back to some of my first memories of the holidays. I remember Santa visiting our home, arriving in a 1968 Buick LeSabre. I was just 2, and the memories are still fresh; the accordion intro, the childish voice singing “Must be Santa” backed by the men singing baritone, an ear-worm I’ll take to my last breath. I took the LP from my mother's stack, and it's now in mine.
“What Child Is This,” Vince Guaraldi Trio – Grown up I can choose my own music, and Vince Guaraldi’s “A Charlie Brown Christmas” album is the one my children will remember me by. Particularly “What Child is This.” It swings and soothes to my soul’s particular cadence, it’s more meaningful to me that Midnight Mass.
“Santa Claus Go Straight To The Ghetto,” James Brown – My wife’s first job was working payroll for a record distribution company in Cleveland. She was given a compilation album that includes this soulful and heartwarming and equally heartbreaking track that my children heard in my holiday rotation, James Brown’s “Santa Claus Go Straight To The Ghetto.” Brown sings with such conviction, anger and love. It was released in 1968, a push-back to the sanitized holiday tracks by Andy Williams and the rest. I guiltily swing to Brown’s saxophone player and the cadence of an electric guitar as James belts out his plea to Santa. A call for charity to all, no matter race or creed.
Brian Ruh
Brian Ruh first moved to West Lafayette as a kid and went to fifth- through eighth grades here (Cumberland, Burtsfield, then the West Lafayette Junior High). He moved back in 1995 to go to Purdue. He and his family moved back again 10 years ago after stints in Bloomington and Austin, Texas (and far too much grad school). He now works in IT for Purdue Federal Credit Union and can occasionally be seen in some local theater (like Acorn's upcoming "Murder on the Nile" in March 2025).
"Blue Christmas,” Squirtgun – I’m going to start with a song that probably can't be added to the compiled list because it's not on Spotify. Yes, that's just the kind of person I am. But I couldn't have such a list omit a Christmas song from this local punk band. (I'll still call them a local band even though half of the members now live on the other side of the Atlantic.) I remember the thrill of getting the 7-inch blue vinyl record in the mail in college when I was living at McCutcheon Hall. Now I somehow have three copies of the record, but I no longer own a record player.
"Angels We Have Heard on High,” MU330 – I’ll keep things in the realm of Midwestern punk for yet another cover – this time of one of my favorite traditional Christmas songs.
"Somebody to Love,” George Michael – Is this a holiday song? Yes, because of two reasons: 1. Whamageddon. That game that's become popular where you try to avoid hearing Wham!'s "Last Christmas" for as long as you can during the Christmas season. I actually quite dislike the game. "Last Christmas" is a great song. And this marks all Wham! (and George Michael by extension) as at least Christmas-adjacent. 2. This song, performed live at the Freddie Mercury Tribute Concert in 1992 with the rest of the members of Queen, is made even more poignant after the passing of George Michael on Christmas Day eight years ago. Listen to this song, remember Freddie and George, and appreciate the people you have this season.
Jay McCann
McCann is a political science professor at Purdue.
“Belleau Wood,” Garth Brooks – When teaching political science students about how conflicts might be resolved through recognition of common values or common needs, I’ve pointed to the “Christmas Truce” during World War I. In the late-‘90s, Garth Brooks released a song that commemorates this truce.
“Accordion Bells,” Leo Kottke – On a more personal note, Leo Kottke is one of my guitar heroes. Here he is doing “Accordion Bells,” which has appeared on Christmas albums.
“Auld Lang Syne,” Julie Fowlis – And if your readers are also thinking about the calendar turning to 2025, here’s a wonderful live version of Auld Lang Syne by the Scottish performer Julie Fowlis.
RG Skadberg
From RG Skadberg, an attorney and former DJ, including stints at WAZY: “Over the 20 years I spent in radio, I played thousands Christmas songs. I think there are only, actually, 27 different songs, but thousands of different versions. Here are three that stand out for me.”
“Oh, Holy Night,” Kerrie Roberts – Originally released on “The Essentials Christmas Collection” in 2010. My absolute favorite song that can take me to a dozen completely different memories, at different times of my life, in a chorus. Kerrie’s version cuts through over production with a voice that is as stunning is as it is effortless – like the strings accompanying her. It could be on repeat for hours, and I will still get chills and tears.
“A Christmas Rose,” Lafayette Jefferson High School Choral Ensemble (1983-ish) – Delta Records approached choir directors Gary and Jean Branson in 1983 about recording a Christmas album. Their (our) annual Christmas shows would sell out three or four shows a season. While the album does include our eight-plus part version of “Oh, Holy Night,” “A Christmas Rose” is the standout song for me. I don’t think I’ve ever heard it anywhere else. On an aside, when we moved my mom out of her home of 50 years, I found a handful of unopen, never-played albums she must have felt obligated to buy. Still have them if anyone is interested.
“Linus and Lucy,” Vince Guaraldi Trio – The quintessential Peanuts song that we all grew up with. Featured in one of the anchor Christmas specials we anticipated every year. The complexity of the music on paper is beyond intimidating. The simplicity of three jazz musicians delivering such an upbeat and joy-filled song lifts me up and takes me to a happy place every time.
Brian Garrity
Brian Garrity is corporate support manager for WBAA/WFYI.
“It Came Upon a Midnight Clear,” Celtic Women – My favorite.
“Oh Holy Night,” Andy Williams – My mom’s favorite.
“Jingle Bells,” Frank Sinatra – It’s just fun twist on a classic.
Rich Hogan
Rich Hogan is a professor emeritus of sociology at Purdue.
“Spirit of Christmas,” Ray Charles – This is a charming holiday wish from one of the great ones.
“Baby It's Cold Outside,” Ella Fitzgerald – This is a somewhat naughty song be a grand lady of the jazz worlds.
“Backdoor Santa,” B.B. King – Talk about naughty. He was the King.
Catherine Grossman
Catherine Grossman lives in West Lafayette.
“Christmas in Hollis,” Run DMC – One of my first teaching jobs in 1987 was with adjudicated youth in a high school, and it was there I first heard rap. The backstory of the origins of rap made me like it even more.
“Santa Claus is Comin' To Town,” The Dave Brubeck Quartet – Love all the jazzy holiday songs.
“Walking in a Winter Wonderland,” Jon Batiste – I walked many a snowstorm in Michigan in my youth, and this song is always associated with romance.
Thank you for supporting Based in Lafayette, an independent, local reporting project. Free and full-ride subscription options are ready for you here.
Tips, story ideas? I’m at davebangert1@gmail.com.